What’s more delicious than peanut butter and chocolate?? This fudgy peanut butter chocolate cake has 6 layers of moist chocolate cake with smooth peanut butter buttercream between each layer. It’s then topped with chocolate ganache and a generous amount of peanut butter cups. It’s basically heaven in a slice.
Tips for making moist chocolate cake
One major half of this recipe is the rich and moist chocolate cake. It’s a delicious recipe that can be utilized for this peanut butter chocolate cake OR as a solid chocolate cake recipe on its own. Either way, here are my top tips to make sure it turns out just right:
Dry Ingredients – I say this in every post, and for good reason. If dry ingredients are not measured properly, the cake will turn out dry and crumbly. If possible, measure the flour with a food scale. Otherwise, to ensure the exact amount, gently spoon the flour (and cocoa powder) into a measuring cup and level if off with a flat edge. If scooped directly into the flour container, the flour becomes packed into the cup which can lead to 1/4 cup or more of added flour.
Dutch Process Cocoa – Dutch processed is great for baking because it gives a really rich flavor and color but it does not react with baking soda, so it can sometimes be an issue in cakes. Due to the added vinegar in this recipe, this will react the baking soda thus creating a lifted cake. This is also why it’s important to not swap the dutch process cocoa with regular unsweetened cocoa as this is acidic. The extra acid could cause the cake to bake differently.
Mixing – Mix as much as you want with the wet ingredients, but once the dry ingredients are added it’s very important to gently mix the batter. Over mixing can lead to a tough cake, so take your time working the flour mix into the wet ingredients.
Cake Strips – This is optional, but wrapping the cake pans in damp cake strips before baking will lead to a much more even bake.
How to make a 6 layer peanut butter chocolate cake
This recipe is baked in 3 layers of chocolate cake, but overall there are 6 cake layers total.
The even layers of both chocolate cake and peanut butter frosting lead to very balanced bites of peanut butter and chocolate, so making 6 layers out of 3 is definitely worth the extra steps!
To create the 6 layers, first level off the tops of each cake layer either by hand with a knife or with a cake leveler.
Once all three layers are even on top, go back and cut each layer in half like a hamburger bun. This can again be done with a cake leveler or by hand with a knife.
Unfortunately for my cake level, I wasn’t able to place it at a height that would split the cake in two even layers so I did this part by hand.
But don’t be intimidated! It’s very easy to cut a cake layer in half. First, place the cake layer in the center of a cake turntable.
Using a large kitchen knife, slice into the side of the cake layer while turning the table. Slowly press the knife into the cake while working your way towards the center of the cake. Eventually, the knife will cut all the way through to reveal two even layers of chocolate cake.
Tips for decorating chocolate peanut butter cake
First, when stacking and layering the cake, match the cake layers with their other half. For example, to start the cake place the bottom half of one of the sliced 3 layers on a cake turntable.
Spread peanut butter frosting on top and then match that cake layer by placing its other half on top. Keeping the halves together will prevent the cake from leaning over.
To finish off the layering, the final cake layer should be the bottom half of one of the 3 halved cakes. Flip this upside down and place it on top of the final layer of peanut butter buttercream. The top of the cake should now be an upside down half layer of chocolate cake. The bottom of the cake is much less porous than the sliced side, so this will prevent the cake from drying out.
Once the cake is stacked, transfer it to the refrigerator while you make the ganache. It’s very important to allow those layers of peanut butter frosting to thicken and set, otherwise the chocolate cake layers could slip out of place.
After the ganache is mixed, let it chill for about 15 minutes before dripping it on the side of the cake. You never want to pour hot ganache on a cake because it can melt the buttercream AND it’s much too thin so it will just run right off the sides of the cake.
To test if it’s ready, spoon a small amount on the side of the cake to create a single drip. If it runs down and then stops before it hits the bottom, it’s ready.
Once the ganache drip is added to the cake, return the cake to the refrigerator again to allow the ganache to set ever so slightly. If the peanut butter cups are added to the fresh ganache, they have the potential to slide off.
When the ganache is still glossy but visibly thickened, decorate the top of the cake with as many peanut butter cups as you like! Gently press them into the ganache to keep them in place.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cake FAQs
Yes! Just use my gluten free chocolate cake recipe in place of the chocolate cake used here.
Yes, once the chocolate cake layers are baked and popped out of the cake pans, allow the layers to cool completely. Then wrap each layer in plastic wrap and store in the refrigerator for a couple days for the freezer for a few months. Then level and slice the cake layers when you’re ready to assemble the cake.
Use standard creamy no-stir peanut butter like Jif or Skippy.
Roughly 3/4 cup of buttercream is the perfect amount for each layer. This recipe makes just enough to cover each layer, but nothing will be left over to frost the outside. If you would like to spread more buttercream on the outside of the cake, double the peanut butter buttercream recipe.
For a completely decorated and frosted cake that is unsliced, store in the refrigerator in an airtight container. If you don’t have a container tall enough, I’ve placed a tall metal pot over the cake and it did the trick! If the cake is sliced into, press some plastic wrap up against the sliced openings and then store in a container in the refrigerator. This cake will stay moist in the refrigerator for about 4 days.
For more chocolate cake recipes, check out my:
- Fudgy Vegan Chocolate Cake
- Gluten Free Chocolate Cake
- Moist Chocolate Cupcakes
- Mint Chocolate Chip Cake
- Fudgy Brownie Cake
Make sure to tag me @butternutbakery on Instagram and leave a review below if you make this chocolate peanut butter cake. To pin this recipe and save it for later, you can use the button on the recipe card, the buttons above or below this post, or on any of the photos above. Happy baking!Print